10
Apr

The Fight For Health Care Reform May Already Be Lost–Unless….

B, SAY IT AIN’T SO:

President Barack Obama asked Congress on Thursday for $83.4 billion for U.S. military and diplomatic operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, pressing for special troop funding that he opposed two years ago when he was senator and George W. Bush was president.

Report From Washington: Will There Be Health Care Reform?
Stress Tests at Banks And the New Bailout To Come
The Pirates Off Somalia: Part of the Untold Story

Wednesday, Washington DC: Congress was in recess, and I was early for my meeting on the Hill, so I wandered the always clean halls of The Rayburn Office Building to get a contact high, make that a contact low, with the political zeitgeist. All the offices were manned and womaned by student interns with instructions not to say anything, not that most had anything to say.

rayburn.jpg

I was burrowing around to find our more about the emerging heath care debate, arguably the most important component of the Obama agenda along with climate change and of course forestalling the complete collapse of the economy. The Administration seems determined to get something through by Fall, and have already begun to compromise before the bill is introduced.

RELATED: Executive Order Establishing The White House Office Of Health Reform

Reports Politco: they see a “strong chance that a GRADUAL (my emphasis) version of his health overhaul will get through Congress this fall. “The Obamacrats have sidelined the idea of universal single payer reform of the kind championed by John Conyers and a nationwide movement of organizations who want to bring the US of A into a world with many countries providing medical care ala our federally managed Medicare system.

The Hill, the newspaper that covers Congress, reports: “Dems Face Familiar Obstacles In Health Care Debate.” It paints the old picture of a divided party trying to please diametrically opposed positions and factions. No real consensus. No real leadership.

Killing single payer seems to be part of a strategy to forge a “consensus” on a plan that will pass muster with the humongous health insurance industry. Recently, PBS Frontline, which hailed government backed health care programs in other countries, did a show on the American system dumping single payer as an option. Doing so was an editorial decision lambasted by health care activist Jerry Policoff in Pennsylvania, who berated them in a strong letter to Frontline:

“Your so-called “documentary,”Sick Around America” was a disgrace. Why is PBS so interested in helping wealthy corporate interests in the health insurance and pharmaceutical industries suppress any meaningful discussion of single-payer health care? Your own previous special, “Sick Around the World,” documented how well it works around the world, yet when it comes to dealing with the health care crisis in this country, you shut single-payer out as not even meriting mention while giving Karen Ignani, a shameless and dishonest shill for the health insurance industry, a platform for misrepresenting health care systems around the world as for-profit systems with mandates. That is the system Ms. Ignani wants for the United States, but it exists nowhere else in the world, and no other country would allow it. For her to suggest the opposite was a deliberate misrepresentation that your interviewer complacently went along with and even repeated. No wonder T.R. Reid disassociated himself from this dishonest endeavor…

PBS has become a propaganda arm for the health insurance industry, and I am disgusted with you. You owe your viewers an apology and you probably owe T.R. Reid and your viewers a do-over, but I won’t hold my breath.”

Wow.

ds_health_2.jpg

(Not to be outdone, in another instance of mainstream media “fairness” (sic) on Thursday the New York Times gave prominent and lengthy placement on its op-ed page to a diatribe against universal health care to a writer from the right-wing National Review. No other point of view challenged him.)

Nixing A Public Option

The National Journal, a policy magazine read widely in Congress has a cover story about mounting opposition to what’s called a “public option,” a plan that would cover everyone like Medicare but from birth. The unions are for it. The people need it, especially the tens of millions without health insurance. The insurance lobbyists are against it along with Republicans.

Reports The Journal: “The current struggle is part of the long ideological tug-of-war over the appropriate role of government health care.”

I guess government administered health care is “ok” for members of Congress, and the military, and people over 65 but not younger people and people in need. (Remember: we pay into these funds. It is our money!)

What’s the problem? Money! The doctors and hospitals oppose it because they fear for their fees. The Republicans say they fear it will increase the federal deficit. Both have a message for the millions of Americans without heath care — “tough sh*t!”

The battle lines are being drawn once again. The lobbyists are working to stop effective health care reform unless their industry can control and profit from it.

And Obama????? He seems to be waffling.

Progressives are lining up behind a plan introduced in Washington when I was there. Roger Hickey, OurFuture.org, supports an approach outlined in a new report:

“Jacob Hacker’s 2006 book, “The Great Risk Shift,” helped politicians understand the economic pressures on the average family — including the rising costs and increasing loss of health insurance — or the threat. Today we are releasing an important report by Dr. Jacob Hacker. It is entitled, “Healthy Competition; How to Structure Public Health Insurance Plan Choice to Ensure Risk-Sharing, Cost Control, and Quality Improvement.” READ FULL STORY HERE

*******

ds_healtcare.jpg

Escalating Health Care Costs, Diminishing Access to Care and Persistent Gaps in Quality — Families, business, and state and federal budgets are straining under skyrocketing health care costs. This report shows how the current system has failed millions of Americans and why we must enact comprehensive health reform this year. READ FULL STORY HERE

*******

There are many ways to skin this big cat BUT unless the health industry lobby and its many paid spokespeople, in Congress and out, are challenged and stopped, we may end up with one more round of frustration and betrayal. That translates into change not worth believing in.

That’s why some in Congress are looking outside their hallowed and haunted halls for help in reaching and mobilizing the American people. They see a need to connect out to artists and celebrities to help make this issue THE issue, to mobilize the country with songs and more effective speechifying to get the public to realize they/we have to act if we want real health care reform.

ds_health_1.jpg

Years ago, as part of the group that made the anti-apartheid Sun City album and video and then worked on the multi-artist,” We Are Family,” song and video in the aftermath of 911, I know that artist driven projects can be powerful. Bono’s work on behalf of debt and AIDs relief in Africa is one model for this type of advocacy.

Health care reform is too important to be left to compromised politicians committed to speaking out of all sides of their motor mouths. We need a new force and community in this debate to shake the tree of truth. Attention artists, actors, musicians: this affects you too. I hope that the “stars” will be responsive when asked to get involved.

One example in the right direction. Actor Mike Farrell, of MASH fame, has already done a video appeal to the Obama Administrations supporting single-payer. It’s a pretty good ad.

Any artists and entertainers out there who want to help? Contact: dissector@mediachannel.org

Post to Twitter

Share/Save/Bookmark

Comments are closed.

Click Here to Book Danny Schechter for Speaking Appearences

Danny Schechter "The News Dissector" has been offering a counter narrative to news and perspectives on global issues, politics and culture since l970 - on radio, TV and, for the last decade, on this blog. Danny edits MediaChannel.org, writes this daily blog as well as articles, commentaries, polemics, screeds, rants and books. His latest book is PLUNDER and he is now making a film on the economic crisis that the book explores - View Trailer Here.

His latest film is BARACK OBAMA, PEOPLE'S PRESIDENT (for Videovision)
























Comments and items/stories for the NEWS DISSECTOR blog can be sent to Dissector @ mediachannel.org. The blog is now produced with Dissectrix Cherie Welch.

If you like what we are doing, forward the blog to friends and urge them to subscribe for free.

You can support our work with tax-deductible donations made out to THE GLOBAL CENTER, 575 8th Avenue #2200, NY, NY 10018. You can also contribute Via PAYPAL.

Archives


Books I Like


Purchases help
support this blog!

  • Censored 2005: The Top 25 Censored Stories (Censored)
    Censored 2005: The Top 25 Censored Stories (Censored)
    Author: Project Censored
    Rating: 0

My Movies


IN DEBT WE TRUST
Why are so many Americans are being strangled by debt? In Debt We Trust is a journalistic confrontation with the debt and credit industry.

WMD
Weapons of Mass Deception (WMD) goes inside the military-media complex, exposing the war the world saw but Americans didn't.

Plunder: Investigating Our Economic Calamity


Plunder: Investigating Our Economic Calamity

By Danny Schechter
As millions of homes are foreclosed upon, as unemployment grows and inflation mounts, it is time to understand the origins of the crisis and the need to fight for economic justice.

Click here to buy it! >>









Home Sweet Home Project


Home Sweet Home Project

Shock Jocks:
Hate Speech and
Talk Radio

Shock Jocks: Hate Speech and Talk Radio

Written by veteran media critic and Emmy winner Rory O'Connor, Shock Jocks features unsparing profiles of the ten worst conservative radio talkers in America, including Michael Savage, Bill O' Reilly, Rush Limbaugh, Don Imus and the rest.

Click here to buy it! >>



Soundbyte

"Curtailment of free speech is rationalized on grounds that a more compelling American tradition forbids criticism of the government when the nation is at war...Nothing can be more destructive of our fundamental democratic traditions than the vicious effort to silence dissenters."
—Martin Luther King, Jr.

Indymedia.us

Member of Media Bloggers Association
  • Media Bloggers

  • Media Columnists

  • News and Commentary