Danny asked me to share these comments with you.

Martha Older responds to Danny’s recent post about MoveOn’s move to the middle. She begins with an excerpt:

I have been getting lots of my response to my post on MoveOn. Let me be clear. I think MoveOn has an important role to play and I am not out to trash the organization, not at all. I grew up in a time when we debated political issues, not played follow the leader.

I hope that its members can convince the ‘team’ that runs Move On to reexamine in stance on the MORAL and political issue of our time–the war on Iraq. I welcome comments from MoveOn and responses. I will run more as they come in.

I am in total agreement with this. MoveOn is a large and important organization with much power. As of yet, there’s no alternative, and it wouldn’t matter if there were – we need to attempt to CHANGE it, not just leave it.

I saw a demonstration of their power when we (Coalition Against Election Fraud, caef.us) were lobbying for Senators to challenge certification of Ohio on Wednesday, Jan. 6. On Monday eve. a member of a group we were allied with (PDA, possibly) convinced MoveOn to get their members to call selected Senators. I was in Feingold’s office Tues and Weds. The receptionists did nothing but answer the ceaseless, overlapping phone calls – on Tuesday they got over 600. This means many more people failed to get through the busy signals. (Boxer’s office had been paralyzed for days between phone calls and lobbying.) This sort of thing is VERY effective.

We need this organization – but we also need it to be truly progressive. So we must redirect it, and the sooner the better.

Lorna S, a MoveOn member, wrote us Monday to share a new letter from the organization. She writes, “This came to me in today’s email. Is this a half-hearted effort to change their tune? … or just icing to sweeten their changed focus?”

This Saturday will mark the second anniversary of the Iraq war.

Join a Sojourners vigil to remember those we’ve lost and recommit ourselves to a better way. Locate a vigil in your area at:

Dear MoveOn member, (3-15-05)

March 19th, 2005 will mark 2 full years since the bombs started falling in Iraq. As of today, 1,516 American troops have been killed in combat, and over 11,220 have been seriously injured. Uncounted tens of thousands of Iraqi civilians have died, and millions are without electricity or running water. The Bush administration is in the middle of an optimism campaign on Iraq, and wants us to believe that a stable peace is around the corner. But most realists see years of chaos and violence ahead. The two-year anniversary of the invasion is an important time to come together in response.

Our friends at Sojourners–a network of progressive faith-based communities–are organizing peace vigils all across the country, and they have asked MoveOn members to join them. You can either find a vigil in your neighborhood, or start one of your own. It’s a first step–an opportunity to mark this date with a solemn recognition of those we have lost, and a firm commitment to finding a better way.

To find a vigil near you, just go to:
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=654

To host a vigil, go to:
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=655

The vigils will take many different forms. Some are hosted by churches, synagogues and mosques and include religious prayers. Some are hosted by local peace groups and are non-denominational. Resources are available online to help you organize either type. Common elements include reading the names of fallen Americans and Iraqis, prayer for peace, and silence.

This anniversary is also an important time to reflect on the war itself, and where we go from here. The fundamental error of the invasion has left us, as a nation, with no opportunity for a quick fix. But together, we must address the catastrophe Bush has created, and ensure we are never again deceived into a reckless war.

Last summer, we surveyed MoveOn members to determine where folks stood on Iraq. An overwhelming majority of us agreed that we need to have a clear exit plan. And that consensus remains: in order to gain the trust of the Iraqi people, they must know that we don’t intend to be there forever.

In the days ahead, we will work together to end the war, by pressuring the President to negotiate a binding exit plan with the Iraqi government. We will push to ensure that America doesn’t establish permanent military bases in Iraq, which would send such a terrible message to the world about our motives there.

Together, we will demand that Congress root out the corporate corruption that has undercut the rebuilding efforts and washed billions we’ve already put into Iraq down the drain. This is especially crucial as Congress prepares to approve another $80+ billion for Iraq.

And we will counter the Bush doctrine of shortsighted, go-it-alone militarism by promoting healthy engagement with the international community–the best way to accomplish diplomatic goals, and address real security threats.

Finally, we’ll organize to increase the political consequences for misleading the country into war. Future lawmakers must know that illegitimate wars come at a great political cost.

Our work together goes on. But this Saturday, let’s begin by commemorating what has happened, mourning those we have lost and building hope together for a more peaceful world.

To find and join a two-year anniversary peace vigil, click here:
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=654

To host your own vigil, click here
http://www.moveon.org/r?r=655

Thanks for all that you do to make the world a more secure and peaceful place.

Sincerely,

–Eli Pariser, Ben Brandzel and the MoveOn.org Team
March 15th, 2005